Discovering The 15 Best Restaurants in Island Park (Idaho)

Looking for the best restaurants in Island Park Idaho? We’re a group of food enthusiasts at Travelpediaonline, always on the lookout for the best places to dine when we explore new destinations. Island Park got its name because it has many open spaces and wooded areas near the water where travelers could stop and take a break or conduct their business.

Island Park offers a variety of attractions like Big Springs, Harriman State Park, Sheep Falls, and activities for both summer and winter. You can enjoy horseback riding, mountain biking, visit historic Henry’s Lake, Mesa Falls, try fly fishing, or relax by the Island Park Reservoir. And when it comes to food, this city won’t disappoint. You can savor delicious dishes including pizzas, salads, soups, burgers, desserts, drinks, grills, tacos, steaks, and the finest Mexican and Italian cuisine.

Some of the notable restaurants in Island Park are Ponds Lodge, TroutHunter, Henry’s Fork Lodge, and many more. Get ready to tantalize your taste buds with the incredible flavors this place has to offer. To make your dining choices easier, we’ve compiled a comprehensive list of the best restaurants in Island Park Idaho, based on reviews from Google Maps and other sources. You’ll find the most popular spots at the top of our list.

If you’re planning a visit to the charming coastal town of Ocean City, Maryland, be sure to explore the culinary delights it has to offer, including some of the best seafood restaurants in Ocean City, Maryland, where you can savor the freshest catches.

Here are the 15 best restaurants in Island Park Idaho:

1. Ponds Lodge


Ponds Lodge, one of the best restaurants in Island Park Idaho, originally began as a humble café, overnight lodging, and separate dance halls. Situated within the main lodge, the restaurant and bar have remained a constant amidst the ebb and flow of time and various management changes. 

Today, it stands strong, dedicated to providing exceptional services for weddings, corporate gatherings, reunions, and any other events you may be planning. Their diverse menu caters to various dietary preferences, offering gluten-free and vegetarian-friendly options. Don’t miss out on their Tuesday pizza specials. 

Other tempting menu items include grilled cheese, corndogs, Caesar salad, spicy chicken fish tacos, Idaho potato skins, cheese sticks, and the classic wedge, all complemented by a carefully curated wine selection. Noteworthy signature dishes to savor include The Josh Roth, The Papi Karl, and The Doc Holiday. Ponds Lodge welcomes guests daily from 11:00 am to 10:00 pm.

Address: 3757 North Highway 26, Island Park, ID 83429, United States

2. River Front Restaurant at the Anglers Lodge


If you’re in search of a tranquil setting to relish outstanding American cuisine, you’ve come to the perfect place. River Front restaurant offers the ideal retreat, allowing you to dine al fresco with direct access to fly-fishing, snowmobile trails, and the mesmerizing waterfront for sunset vistas. Inside, River Front boasts a cozy ambiance with cabin-style decor, wooden walls, and stone accents that provide a delightful atmosphere.

On the menu, you’ll find an array of delectable dishes and desserts, including the bison burger, chicken smokehouse, shrimp ceviche, kale salad, and the indulgent chocolate lava cake. Start your culinary journey with the enticing appetizer, “Old Faithful Campfire Dip.” Pair your meal with their selection of draft beers, fine wines, and irresistible desserts. Renowned as one of the best restaurants in Island Park Idaho, River Front invites you to join them every day from 5:00 pm to 10:00 pm, welcoming families, friends, and even pets for a memorable dining experience.

Address: 3363 Old Highway 191, Island Park, ID 83429-5125, United States

3. TroutHunter


TroutHunter stands out as a premier establishment among bars, offering a diverse selection of American cuisine in the picturesque setting of Island Park. Renowned for its exceptional, speedy, and welcoming service, this establishment was founded in 1999 and continues to epitomize hospitality, providing a relaxed yet inviting atmosphere and crafting mouthwatering dishes using the freshest ingredients, catering to patrons from around the world. 

Their core mission revolves around nurturing and fostering lasting connections with their valued customers. At TroutHunter, your taste buds can delight in a variety of culinary delights, including pancakes, the hearty mountain man breakfast, and the classic eggs benedict. The lunch menu boasts tantalizing options such as coconut shrimp, flavorful Asian noodles, and the refreshing Caprese bruschetta. 

Don’t miss out on their daily specials, featuring scrumptious salads, savory beef bowls, lettuce wraps, last chance chicken wings, and the iconic Philly cheese sandwich. TroutHunter unquestionably ranks among the top dining destinations in Island Park, Idaho, and a visit will affirm this reputation. They warmly welcome guests every day from 8:00 am to 10:00 pm.

Address: 3327 N Highway 20, Island Park, ID 83429-5134, United States

4. Connie’s Restaurant


One of the best restaurants in Island Park Idaho, that you shouldn’t miss is Connie’s Restaurant. For a remarkable 25 years, Connie’s Restaurant has consistently delivered perfection in every dish they serve. It’s a place that feels like a home away from home, where you can savor a delightful meal while engaging in wonderful conversations with your loved ones. 

This family-friendly establishment proudly boasts being the origin of the renowned Saw Tell Burger and delectable prime rib. Connie’s Restaurant offers an extensive menu featuring options such as grilled chicken salad, taco salad, spaghetti meatball, seafood fettuccini, finger steaks, filet mignon, green beans fries, fried jumbo shrimp, humdinger chili dog, grandma’s chicken & noodles, and more. 

You can expect top-notch food quality, attentive and friendly service, complimentary off-street parking, the convenience of reservations, card payments, and even the option to pre-order lunch boxes. Operating hours at Connie’s Restaurant are as follows: Sundays and Mondays from 04:00 pm to 09:00 pm, Thursdays from 11:00 am to 09:00 pm, and Fridays and Saturdays from 11:00 am to 10:00 pm.

Address: 4130 Quakie Ln, Island Park, ID 8342-5301, United States

5. Cafe Sabor


Are you tired of the regular burgers, pizza & chicken? Look no further than Cafe Sabor, your destination for authentic Mexican cuisine crafted from the freshest ingredients. Founded in 2002, this restaurant, situated in the heart of picturesque Logan, Utah, is deeply committed to giving back to the communities that have played a pivotal role in its growth.

Cafe Sabor’s diverse menu features vegetarian-friendly options such as vegetarian burritos, spinach artichokes, Chino Latino eggrolls, chimichangas, steak picado, seafood mango shrimp, nachos, and the flavorful fajita burrito. 

While the Island Park area may not be known for its abundance of excellent Mexican dining options, Cafe Sabor stands out as a unique gem. You can savor the flavors of Cafe Sabor in Island Park every day from 11:00 am to 09:00 pm, offering a delightful outdoor dining experience, convenient takeout services, and a welcoming atmosphere for your social gatherings.

Address: 4294 US Highway 20, Island Park, ID 8433, United States

Nestled in the heart of the picturesque Rocky Mountains, Manitou Springs, CO, boasts a vibrant culinary scene, with a diverse array of dining options to suit every palate, making it easy to discover the best restaurants in Manitou Springs, CO, that will satisfy your cravings and provide a memorable dining experience.

6. The Munching Moose’s Mobile Kitchen


Have you ever had the pleasure of dining at one of the best restaurants in Island Park Idaho, a mobile trailer restaurant? If not, this is your chance to savor their culinary creations. They pour their creativity and passion into every dish they serve, and they’re eager to share this experience with you. 

Delight in a variety of their top-notch offerings, such as smoked pork, Indian tacos, hamburgers, Mexican street corn shooters, corn spoon bread, bone-in chicken, antipasto, citrus vinaigrette, and more. Munching Moose’s welcomes guests from Tuesday to Saturday, opening at 10:00 am and closing at 06:00 pm. Be sure to pay them a visit when they’re open – this establishment truly ranks among the finest restaurants in Island Park Idaho.

Address: 5160 N, Hwy 20, Island Park, ID 83429, United States

7. The Parlor at Mack’s Inn


If you’re craving some ice cream, a must-visit spot is The Parlor at Mack’s Inn, nestled inside the Spring Hill Suites in Island Park. This delightful establishment offers a delectable selection of wood-fired pizzas, tantalizing blue-bird chocolates sourced from the iconic blue-bird candy in Logan, Utah, and the renowned Farr’s ice cream.

The menu boasts mouthwatering highlights such as salads, cheesecake marshmallows, and a variety of pizzas including pepperoni, margarita, and Hawaiian. Indulge in a diverse range of ice cream flavors, from Rocky Road and vanilla to Huckleberry, cookie dough, S’More Aggie, mango sorbet, and more.

Plan your visit to The Parlor from Tuesdays to Saturdays, between 11:00 am and 09:00 pm, as it remains closed on Sundays and Mondays. Please note that their hours may vary on Fridays, especially during Black Friday events.

Address: 4292 US-20, Island Park, ID 83429, United States

8. Henry’s Fork Lodge & Restaurant


Among the top-rated restaurants in Island Park Idaho, you’ll find Henry’s Fork. This establishment is particularly popular among fly fishing enthusiasts. Whether you’re stopping by for a special meal or spending the night at the lodge, you’re in for an unforgettable experience.

Henry’s Fork takes pride in serving farm-fresh and ranch-sourced ingredients prepared by skilled chefs, delivering a dining experience on par with city restaurants. Their menu boasts delectable options such as roasted butternut squash soup, grilled trumpet with curried yogurt sauce, Pinot Noir, potato confit hash, and sustainably sourced seafood.

If you’re unsure about your dinner choice, don’t worry – their evening dining is referred to as “match the hatch.” Start with hors d’oeuvres and drinks, where you can share stories from the day’s outdoor adventures. Henry’s Fork is open from Sundays through Saturdays, from 06:00 pm to 08:30 pm.

Address: 2794 S, Pinehaven Drive, Island Park, 83529-5219, United States

9. Meadow Creek Lodge


Meadow Creek Lodge is your go-to spot for delicious burgers and fries. This charming old Lodge offers a versatile dining experience, whether you’re looking for a quick bite, takeout, or a cozy seat at the bar with your favorite drinks. Even if you’re heading out for a snowmobile adventure, don’t worry – Meadow Creek restaurant welcomes you with open arms, serving up hearty home-style cooking and treating you like part of their family.

Their menu features mouthwatering options like cheeseburgers, grilled cheese, bacon hamburgers, grilled chicken breast, fries, sandwiches, and comforting beverages like hot chocolate and coffee. Keep in mind that Meadow Creek is closed on Mondays but opens its doors from Tuesdays through Saturdays, starting at 08:00 am and closing at 08:00 pm. On Sundays, you can enjoy their offerings from 08:00 am to 06:00 pm.

Address: 4954 Meadow Creek Road, Island Park, ID 83429, United States

10. Subway


If you’re searching for the best restaurants in Island Park Idaho, consider Subway. This renowned establishment is famous for delivering your favorite dishes bursting with delicious flavors that are sure to satisfy anyone looking for a delightful meal.

Subway’s menu features a variety of options, including salads, wraps, sandwiches, and their signature footlongs. You can also tantalize your taste buds with their delectable choices like the egg & cheese wrap, roasted turkey, hickory ham, and Black Forest ham.

For those seeking something extraordinary, don’t miss their specials like the smoked bacon sandwich, composed of American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, and red onions, all nestled between toasted Italian bread. Another fantastic option is the Club Monster, which boasts an assortment of premium meats and vegetarian-friendly selections.

Convenience is key at Subway; you can place your orders online, dine in at the restaurant, or opt for curbside pickup. Additionally, if you plan ahead, Subway can cater small bites and meals for your events. You’ll be delighted to know that Subway is open every day of the week, from 10:00 am to 07:00 pm, ensuring you can enjoy their mouthwatering offerings whenever you desire.

Address: 4141 Saw Tell Peak Rd, Island Park, 82429, United States

While exploring the vibrant nightlife of the Big Apple, don’t miss the chance to elevate your evening by visiting some of the best rooftop bars in New York City, where you can enjoy breathtaking skyline views and handcrafted cocktails that epitomize the city’s unique charm.

11. The Pines at Island Park


Are you in search of the best restaurants in Island Park Idaho for a tranquil yet adventurous getaway? Look no further than The Pines. It stands out as one of the top dining and lodging options in Island Park. Formerly known as the Lodge Poll Grill, The Pines offers cozy cabins, delectable cuisine, a welcoming staff, and much more to provide a homely experience.

Besides indulging in various exciting activities, such as golfing and hunting, you can savor their signature dishes, including coconut shrimp, cabbage, codfish, cheeseburger, and apple pie, all available for online ordering. The Pines welcomes guests from Mondays to Saturdays, operating from 09:30 am to 08:00 pm, and on Sundays, they’re open from 09:45 am to 08:00 pm.

Address: 3909 Philip Loop Rd, Island Park, United States

12. Lakeside Lodge & Resort


Lakeside stands out as one of the finest dining establishments in Island Park, Idaho, and true to its name, it offers a picturesque lakeside setting. This family-friendly restaurant provides the perfect atmosphere for enjoyable conversations. Whether you prefer dining indoors, at the bar, or on the patio, you’ll have the opportunity to savor a diverse menu featuring classic American dishes, steaks, delectable desserts, and a variety of seafood options.

Some of their mouthwatering offerings include generous portions of big flatbread pizza, flavorful Lakeside wings, the savory black and blue NY steak, satisfying nachos, classic burgers, and their signature “Miller tench burgers,” among other delights. Lakeside’s menu also caters to vegan and gluten-free dietary preferences. You can relish their delicious fare any day of the week, as they’re open from 08:00 am to 09:30 pm.

Address: 3857 Lakeside Lodge lane, Island Park, ID 83429, United States

13. The Cafe at Island Park Lodge


The Cafe at Island Park Lodge holds a distinguished place among the best restaurants in Island Park Idaho. As one of the oldest and most iconic lodges in the community, it has been a cherished establishment since 1947.

Over the years, this restaurant has seen numerous renovations and updates, always maintaining its well-deserved reputation. The meals here are not only delicious but also exceptionally hearty, making it a must-visit destination. For breakfast, you can savor options like campfire scramble, pancakes, and sticky rolls. During lunchtime, the menu offers a variety of salads, burgers, and sandwiches.

Don’t miss out on their delectable specials, such as chili bawn, meatloaf, crispy fries, and the ultimate Mac & cheese, among others. Keep in mind that The Cafe at Island Park Lodge is closed on Mondays and Tuesdays, but you can enjoy their offerings from Wednesday through Sunday, with operating hours from 07:00 am to 05:00 pm.

Address: 4149 N Big Springs Loop Rd, Island Park, United States

14. Lodge Poll Grill


Situated within the historic Philips Lodge at the pines, Lodge Poll Grill offers its patrons the unique experience of outdoor seating, even amid snowy conditions. Alternatively, for those who prefer indoor comfort, you can expect nothing less than their exceptional meals served alongside cozy fireplaces to keep you warm on chilly evenings.

Indulge in a delightful culinary journey with dishes such as chicken steak, halibut fish & chips, Cobb salad, loaded baked potato soup, cowboy burger, ribeye steak, seafood platter, espresso con pan, and other menu highlights. Plan your visit accordingly as Lodge Poll Grill remains closed on Mondays and Tuesdays but extends a warm welcome from Wednesdays to Saturdays, operating from 11:00 am to 08:00 pm.

Address: 3907 Philips Loop Rd, The Pines at Island Park, Island Park, United States

15. Buffalo Run Rv Park & Cabins


Buffalo Run RV, a hidden culinary treasure among the best restaurants in Island Park Idaho, is a must-visit destination. Renowned for crafting exquisite Italian cuisine, including delectable pizzas, they offer a range of 8 to 14-inch pizzas, customizable with your choice of sauce, whether it be Marinara or ranch dressing. 

Be sure to try their mouthwatering mountain man pepperoni pizza and flavorful Buffalo chicken & Targhee pizza. Buffalo Run RV is open daily, from Mondays through Sundays, serving patrons from 07:00 am to 07:00 pm, ensuring you can savor their exceptional dishes at your convenience.

Address: 3402 N Highway 20, Island Park, United States

When planning your next road trip and considering a stop at Buc-ee’s, it’s essential to know what to expect from Buc-ee’s breakfast menu, hours, and prices, so you can start your day with a delicious meal and make the most of your visit to this iconic convenience store chain.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the top-rated restaurants in Island Park Idaho?

Island Park boasts several top-rated restaurants, including Ponds Lodge, TroutHunter, and Henry’s Fork Lodge. Explore our comprehensive guide for more great dining options!

What activities can I enjoy in Island Park, Idaho?

Island Park offers a wide range of activities, from horseback riding to fly fishing and exploring natural wonders like Big Springs and Harriman State Park. 

How can I find the best places to dine in Island Park Idaho?

Finding the best restaurants in Island Park Idaho is easy with our guide. We’ve curated a list based on Google Maps reviews and other sources, ensuring you’ll discover the finest dining options in this scenic destination.

Can you recommend some family-friendly restaurants in Island Park Idaho?

Absolutely! Island Park offers family-friendly dining options. Check out our blog post for a selection of restaurants that cater to families, including those with kid-friendly menus.

Are there any Mexican or Italian restaurants in Island Park Idaho?

Yes, Island Park has a variety of cuisines to offer, including Mexican and Italian. Explore our list of the “best restaurants in Island Park Idaho” to find these delightful options and more!

Exploring the cultural heritage and natural beauty of the Shenandoah Valley is a delightful experience, and in this comprehensive guide, we’ll uncover the best things to do in Staunton, VA, ensuring your visit to this historic city is filled with memorable adventures and attractions.

What’s the ambiance like at the top restaurants in Island Park Idaho?

The ambiance at Island Park’s top restaurants varies. Whether you’re seeking a rustic lodge experience or a more modern setting, our blog post provides insights into the atmospheres of these dining establishments.

Is there outdoor seating available at Island Park’s best restaurants?

Many of Island Park’s best restaurants offer outdoor seating, allowing you to dine while enjoying the picturesque surroundings. Refer to our guide for restaurants that provide this al fresco option.

How do I make reservations at the top restaurants in Island Park Idaho?

Reservations policies vary by restaurant. We recommend contacting your chosen restaurant directly or visiting their website for reservation details.

Are these restaurants open year-round in Island Park?

While some restaurants in Island Park may have seasonal hours, many operate year-round to cater to both summer and winter visitors. Check the individual restaurant’s website or contact them for their specific hours of operation.

Can I find vegetarian or vegan options at the best restaurants in Island Park Idaho?

Yes, some of the top restaurants in Island Park offer vegetarian and vegan menu items. Our guide highlights restaurants with diverse menus, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a satisfying meal in this beautiful destination!
Discovering the rich history and vibrant culture of this charming Mississippi town is a must, and in this guide, we’ll take you through the best things to do in Vicksburg, MA, ensuring you make the most of your visit to this captivating destination.

Final Thoughts

If you’re seeking a culinary adventure amidst the natural beauty of Island Park, Idaho, look no further. With its breathtaking landscapes and a plethora of activities to enjoy, this charming destination offers more than just scenic views. The best restaurants in Island Park Idaho promise to be a delightful part of your journey. 

From mouthwatering dishes to warm hospitality, places like Ponds Lodge, TroutHunter, Henry’s Fork Lodge, and many others are here to elevate your dining experience. So, as you embark on your Island Park adventure, don’t forget to explore the flavors of this remarkable place.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like